top of page

Blog

Latest Photo Acquisitions: GIs, Bombed-Out German Cities & Panzers


Hamburg, Winter 1943/44. RPPC. Stuart Archive.
Hamburg, Winter 1943/44. RPPC. Stuart Archive.

GI photo of a bombed out city in Germany, c. 1945. Stuart Archive.
GI photo of a bombed out city in Germany, c. 1945. Stuart Archive.

Germans moving through after a battle in a city, c. 1940s. Stuart Archive.
Germans moving through after a battle in a city, c. 1940s. Stuart Archive.

The next four photos are official US Army Photos taken in Germany. The text below each photo provides details. Stuart Archive.
The next four photos are official US Army Photos taken in Germany. The text below each photo provides details. Stuart Archive.

Official Nazi propaganda photo of Brückenkoff, Germany, taken by Heinrich Hoffmann. Details of the back of the photo below. Stuart Archive.
Official Nazi propaganda photo of Brückenkoff, Germany, taken by Heinrich Hoffmann. Details of the back of the photo below. Stuart Archive.


The German caption that accompanied this photo states: Heavy fires in the city are a consequence of senseless occupation by the Bolsheviks. Sept. 1942.
The German caption that accompanied this photo states: Heavy fires in the city are a consequence of senseless occupation by the Bolsheviks. Sept. 1942.

The GI images, marked by subtle motion blur, convey the immediacy of lived moments—unfiltered, instinctive, and often imperfect.

After being haunted by the Brandstätten images in December, I decided to purchase original photographs of WWII bombed out German cities. So far, I have acquired thirteen photographs from vendors in Europe and the US. One of the photos that I acquired was photographed by the official Nazi Photographer, Heinrich Hoffmann (see images above).


GI photo.The back of this photo indicates that this is “the remains of SS Headquarter in  Germany,” but the headquarters were in Berlin and to me this looks to be  more of a rural setting (e.g.stacked logs). Stuart Archive.
GI photograph. The reverse notes this as “the remains of SS Headquarters in Germany,” though the actual headquarters were in Berlin. The rural setting—stacked logs and open terrain—suggests otherwise. Stuart Archive.

Hamburg, June 18, 1944 after British air attack. Real Photo Postcard (RPPC), Stuart Archive.
Hamburg, June 18, 1944 after British air attack. Real Photo Postcard (RPPC), Stuart Archive.

Some of the photographs hold an unexpected artistic quality, suspended between beauty and horror. The GI images, marked by subtle motion blur, convey the immediacy of lived moments—unfiltered, instinctive, and often imperfect. The RPPCs are exquisite in their composition, tonal range, and contrast—each one meticulously framed. The seller I purchased them from has additional photographs of bombed-out German cities that I’m eager to acquire, though the prices remain high. The U.S. Army photos, too, feel like simulacra—images so composed they seem to echo not just reality, but its reconstruction.


Stuart Archive.
Stuart Archive.
Bombed out German city, taken by GI in 1945. Stuart Archive.
Bombed out German city, taken by GI in 1945. Stuart Archive.

The Liminality in the Sublime


The word sublime comes to mind when I look at these photos. Sublime is a term that connotes both a sense of splendor and awe as well as horror and terror. For something to be sublime means to pass from one state into another and back again. The related word, subliminal, which means something existing or operating below the threshold of awareness---the liminal state between beauty and horror---it is here where an inexplicable emotion that exists below the threshold of awareness that I find myself with these photos.


I consider myself a keeper of dark objects in an attempt to extrapolate meaning and understanding of such homo factus materiae, manmade artifacts that upon deeper analysis and viewing offer a journey into the sublime.


Stuart Archive.
Stuart Archive.
Knocked out Panzers at a battle in a city, c. 1940s. Stuart Archive.
Knocked out Panzers at a battle in a city, c. 1940s. Stuart Archive.

A Growing & Varied Collection


Maintaining a collection like this can feel unsettling at times, especially when certain photos arrive with a distinct psychic charge.

I’ve written about my photo collection before, and various selections appear throughout my blog. Lately, I’ve been reassessing the collection in its entirety—considering where it’s headed, what areas deserve focus, and what, if anything, I’ve outgrown. One subcategory continues to expand with surprising force: original photographs of German aircraft from the Second World War, both intact and destroyed—particularly Messerschmitts and Heinkels. This area alone now warrants a post of its own.


Hans, who flew Messerschmitt Bf 109s exclusively during the war, remains deeply attached to these aircraft. His fascination hasn’t faded with death; if anything, it has sharpened. More than once, he’s orchestrated the sudden appearance of these photographs—surfacing online from nowhere, offered at implausibly low prices. When they do show up in auctions, I tend to win them with minimal resistance, if any at all.


GI photo. Aachen, c. 1940s, Stuart Archive.
GI photo. Aachen, c. 1940s, Stuart Archive.
Stuart Archive.
Stuart Archive.

Since D-Day 2015, my World War II German photo collection has expanded into several subcategories: military portraits, bombed-out German cities, Messerschmitts, Panzers, Dorniers, battle scenes, flak guns, and military formations. All photographs are authentic. If a piece includes period handwriting or an identified photographer, all the better.


Maintaining a collection like this can feel unsettling at times, especially when certain photos arrive with a distinct psychic charge. In rare cases, I’ve been able to apply my skills in psychometry. Antique photographs and objects often carry their own residual energy, sometimes arriving with unexpected visitors from the other side. When that happens, I trust Hans to exercise his gatekeeping abilities as needed. In life as in death, Hans remains a warrior in every sense. I don’t expect him to fight all my battles—responsibility for my actions rests with me—but it’s reassuring to know he has my back when uninvited phenomena cross the threshold.

Comments


bottom of page